The Best VHS in the World
Mordecai and Rigby rent some movies, but are unable to since they haven't returned the last movie they rented, the Best VHS in the World, which M&R though was lame. The Movie Shack Hut Employee tells them that if they don't return it, he will get rid of their membership. M&R tell him that they'll find it and they search the house but can't find. They then have to clean their room so they can find it, but can't. Rigby wonders if someone in the house borrowed it, so they asked everyone. No one had seen it but that they also had some of their items missing. They go back to their room, and find it a mess again. M&R get in a fight over who messed it until a chubby goblin of some kind comes out from M&R's closet. He runs away with the VHS and the two go after him through the air vents. They soon arrive in the goblin's lair and the goblin doesn't give the VHS up. M&R begin telling him that he doesn't need to watch that movie, since it is really bad and there are thousands of movies out in the world that are all better than The Best VHS in the World. The goblin gives in and tells the tape "Don't you worry about old Buttonwillow McButtonwillow." and Rigby laughs at his name. Later, the guys and Buttonwillow go to the Movie Shack Hut and Buttonwillow gets his own membership card, and M&R get theirs back for returning the VHS. The employee asks him what he wants to rent, and Buttonwillow says "I would like The Best VHS in the World."
Characters
Main
Mordecai
Rigby
Movie Shack Hut Employee
Minor
Buttonwillow McButtonwillow
Benson
Muscle Man
Hi Five Ghost
Pops
Skips
Mordecai
Rigby
Movie Shack Hut Employee
Minor
Buttonwillow McButtonwillow
Benson
Muscle Man
Hi Five Ghost
Pops
Skips
M&R cleaning their room A Grilled Cheese Sandwich Buttonwillow McButtonwillow