Pie Contest
Benson is announcing that they are having a pie contest again and that he is judging the pies. Mordecai and Rigby are upset that they are the ones in charge of picking up trash and want to judge the pies. Benson doesn't allow them to until M&R jump in front of the cart, almost killing themselves. Benson tells them they can but if they want to quit, they are fired. Later, they begin trying the pies but find that judging is harder than it seems since if Starla doesn't win, Muscle Man will kill them and if Margaret doesn't win she won't talk to them again. Benson comes into their tent saying that he hasn't bothered to pick up trash(so he is basically pretending to be them)and leaves. They then hear a voice coming from the trash and see a talking pie called Promise Pie who says he can help them decide on the winner. Mordecai declines and Rigby then realizes that they can just give everyone perfect scores so it will be a tie and everyone wins so nobody hates them. They give everyone 10s and at the end of the day, Benson tells them they need to pick a winner. M&R tell him it's a tie so everyone wins but Benson tells them if it's a tie then the winner will need to be decided live in front of everyone. They then go to the pie for help who grows legs and arms and runs out of the tent. He then begins eating everyone. Pops falls into the pie's mouth and Mordecai tells Pops his pie was one of the best ones. Pops comes out of Promise Pie's belly and they realize if they continue judging then everyone will survive. They judge everyone's pie and Pops wins the contest. They then throw Promise Pie at a garbage truck and dies. Benson goes up the guys and yells at them but say he's just mad since he can't fire them anymore. Benson then tells them to clean up the mess or they're fired. Rigby ends the episode wondering if there's any pie left.
Characters
Main
Mordecai
Rigby
Benson
Minor
Pops
Skips
Muscle Man
Hi Five Ghost
Promise Pie
Margaret
John Sorrentstein
Death
Starla
Gary
Eileen
Scabitha
Guy with Pie Glasses
Mordecai
Rigby
Benson
Minor
Pops
Skips
Muscle Man
Hi Five Ghost
Promise Pie
Margaret
John Sorrentstein
Death
Starla
Gary
Eileen
Scabitha
Guy with Pie Glasses